Branding and Identity in the Apache Incubator

Guidance for Podlings on Name and Logo Use

Introduction

Incubating projects carry both the Apache name and their own identity.

Guiding third-party use of the project’s name and logo is an important part of community responsibility.

Misuse can:

  • Confuse users

  • Create the impression of ASF endorsement

  • Undermine ASF’s vendor-neutral reputation

Why Third-Party Branding Matters

  • Protecting the Apache Name

  • Ensuring proper use of the brand

  • Promoting vendor neutrality

  • Supporting graduation

Protecting the Apache Name

  • Every podling carries the prefix Apache

  • Third parties may use ASF marks, but only when following ASF trademark policy.

  • Clear and consistent use protects both the podling and the ASF’s reputation.

  • Safeguarding this shared brand is part of being a responsible community.

Preventing Misrepresentation

  • Third parties must not present software or services as “official” Apache offerings.

  • If this occurs, a friendly early clarification helps maintain trust and prevent confusion.

Preserving Vendor Neutrality

ASF projects are vendor-neutral. If one company markets a podling as its own product, it can create the impression of ownership.

This may lead to:

  • Less participation from others

  • Reduced diversity

  • Graduation delays

Reducing Graduation Risks

  • Branding and trademark management are part of ASF graduation criteria.

  • Projects that handle name and logo use responsibly tend to move through graduation more smoothly.

Common Risks (Part 1)

  • A vendor markets “Apache Foo Enterprise Edition”, implying ASF endorsement

  • A company displays the ASF logo on its commercial website

  • Blogs or press refer to it as “Company X’s project”

  • Promotional material describes it as “owned” or “developed by Company X”

Common Risks (Part 2)

  • Only one vendor is visibly active or commercializing the podling

  • The podling omits “(incubating)” on its website or releases

  • One company’s employees dominate governance or mailing lists

  • Third-party materials (whitepapers, training, blogs) present the project as proprietary

  • Event booths or swag show the logo without “(incubating)” or alongside corporate branding

Branding in Incubator Reports

  • Quarterly reports invite a short branding update.

  • Consider noting:

    • Use of the correct name (“Apache Foo (incubating)”)

    • Third-party mentions checked and any corrections requested

    • Outreach with vendors/events and links to ASF guidance

The “(Incubating)” Disclaimer

Until graduation, use the full name: Apache Foo (incubating)

Display it on:

  • Website, README, docs, and slides

  • Release artifacts and notices

  • Event listings and talk abstracts

Visual Identity and Logos

Podlings may design logos. Aim to:

  • Follow ASF branding guidance

  • Keep project identity distinct from corporate marks

  • Avoid compositions implying endorsement

Events, Press, and Mentions

Proactively check how your project appears in:

  • Conference schedules and CFP sites

  • Vendor blogs, docs, and whitepapers

  • Press releases and analyst notes

Consequences of Not Acting

Unresolved branding issues can:

  • Confuse users and contributors

  • Signal weak neutrality

  • Delay graduation reviews

Good Practices for Podlings

  • Start early: review name/logo use on all surfaces

  • Monitor public mentions periodically

  • Offer polite, specific corrections with ASF links

  • Summarize progress in quarterly reports

  • Ask mentors or trademarks@apache.org when unsure

Branding and Graduation Readiness

Before graduation, reviewers look for:

  • Consistent use of the full name and “(incubating)” qualifier

  • Evidence that the community understands ASF branding principles

  • Balanced, vendor-neutral presentation across project channels

Getting Help

Unsure about a use case?

Conclusion

Taking branding seriously from the start helps podlings:

  • Provide clear signals to users

  • Demonstrate independence and neutrality

  • Show steady progress toward graduation